Ridge Vineyards Petite Sirah Lytton Estate 2002

Straight out of the bottle, you know right away that this wine isn't like most other wines. More than anything else, it's the color that looks strange: surely wine isn't quite that dark? There's a brownish tint that looks more like Kyoto pickle than actual fermented grape juice; it's not age, but intensity that makes it look that way.

On the nose, it's all sweet dusty bramble. In fact, it's so odd that part of me is wondering if the bottle is OK: is that TCA? Brettanomyces? Or is that normal? It's hard to get past the killer sweetness and onto a real wine smell. Jeez, Paul, do you think it would kill you to stop using natural corks? There's almost a smoked bacon note there, but again and again that weird smell takes over. Is it supposed to smell like that?

In the mouth, it gets even stranger: there's a persistent, tooth-coating fuzziness that's fairly unpleasant combined with, well, nothing.

Dang it, this bottle's bad. Glad I bought a pair of them... let's go open the next one...

Well, it almost smelled like wine there for a second, and then poof, it smells like tinfoil and metal shavings. WTF? Same horrible taste: vague sweetness and harsh, grating tannins.

Next week in Full Pour: Will Ridge respond to my E-mail asking about this wine, and if they do, what will they say? User error? We meant for it to taste like you're drinking it out of a Capri-Sun pouch? Gosh, we're sorry, must be a fluke? Gosh, we're really sorry, but they're all bad? Or will they say sorry, nice try, but we don't believe you and won't refund your $60? Stay tuned...

Ridge Vineyards
Price: US $30
Closure: Cork
Date tasted: December 2007


1 Comment

Just to follow up, Ridge cheerfully replaced the wine with two new bottles. I haven't tried them yet, though.

Leave a comment

Recent Entries

  • Dominique Portet Shiraz 2002

    Sadly, I only had one bottle of this left - and I opened it just now only to find that it was corked. Based on...

  • Sandstone Cellars V

    There's something to be said for a wine that makes itself smelled even from across the table. I poured a glass of this, sat down...

  • Cardinham Estate Shiraz 2006

    I have a soft spot for Clare Shiraz and this is good example of the genre, in an easygoing and very much fruit-driven mode. In...

  • Dowie Doole Tintookie Chenin Blanc 2006

    Considered in conventional terms, a more serious wine than its sibling, though to my mind this is an entirely different conversation from whether it's better...

  • Seppelt Jaluka Chardonnay 2007

    Consumed last night out of dodgy glasses, in accompaniment to salty pizza. Despite the challenging circumstances, the wine showed quite well, though it took some...

Close